16: bad-txns-oversize #22

Closed
opened 3 years ago by oDinZu · 5 comments
oDinZu commented 3 years ago
  1. On oldwallet.dat I send 10 Hush from a T address to a new Z address.

I tested with .1, 1 and 10 Hush.

1. On oldwallet.dat I send 10 Hush from a T address to a new Z address. I tested with .1, 1 and 10 Hush.
Poster

more details about it on zcash github /zcash/zcash/issues/1970

more details about it on zcash github `/zcash/zcash/issues/1970`
Poster

yeah, I am having exactly the same problems as Sam on Telegram Hush:Support.

I tested with 0 fee.
I sent many different sizes.

I disabled the shield change from t-addrs to your sapling address and received this error.

16: bad-txns-acprivacy-chain

On terminal output:

CheckTransactionWithoutProofVerification: invalid taddr RGsMk4MmeDLm1xVTL3bi9SwDE17WZBNtf9 on private chain!
found taddr in private chain: z_z.0 z_t.0 t_z.0 vinsize.80

debug.log

2021-08-18 20:04:33 Build: Created spendAuth and binding sigs
2021-08-18 20:04:34 sendrawtransaction: Submitting to mempool
2021-08-18 20:04:34 ERROR: CheckTransaction(): this is a private chain, sending to taddrs not allowed
2021-08-18 20:04:34 ERROR: AcceptToMemoryPool: CheckTransaction failed
2021-08-18 20:04:34 opid-b35e53f1-e52c-4029-b69d-2ea3c9858b20: z_sendmany finished (status=failed, error=16: bad-txns-acprivacy-chain)
yeah, I am having exactly the same problems as Sam on Telegram Hush:Support. I tested with 0 fee. I sent many different sizes. I disabled the shield change from t-addrs to your sapling address and received this error. `16: bad-txns-acprivacy-chain` **On terminal output:** ``` CheckTransactionWithoutProofVerification: invalid taddr RGsMk4MmeDLm1xVTL3bi9SwDE17WZBNtf9 on private chain! found taddr in private chain: z_z.0 z_t.0 t_z.0 vinsize.80 ``` **debug.log** ``` 2021-08-18 20:04:33 Build: Created spendAuth and binding sigs 2021-08-18 20:04:34 sendrawtransaction: Submitting to mempool 2021-08-18 20:04:34 ERROR: CheckTransaction(): this is a private chain, sending to taddrs not allowed 2021-08-18 20:04:34 ERROR: AcceptToMemoryPool: CheckTransaction failed 2021-08-18 20:04:34 opid-b35e53f1-e52c-4029-b69d-2ea3c9858b20: z_sendmany finished (status=failed, error=16: bad-txns-acprivacy-chain) ```
Owner

@oDinZu have you tried sending the total amount of funds that are in the address, with 0 fee?

@oDinZu have you tried sending the total amount of funds that are in the address, with 0 fee?
Owner

@odinzu z_mergetoaddress from ANY_TADDR should work

@odinzu `z_mergetoaddress` from `ANY_TADDR` should work
Poster
hush-cli z_mergetoaddress '["RFJ6Hy48EvEjt-addrqDChxqtqsfyF"]' zs1hm0fgfkf7n4wv9ytce6rdvu7ewrzm0zgr3fq3azaddr 0 0

Works for me. ANY_TADDR probably a more notable solution for the GUI #23.

Adding the 0 transparent_limit is quicker because it doesn't limit to only 50 transactions.

The 0 fee probably shouldn't be used if we don't need to; when using 0 fee it transmits more metadata.

This is great information; we have solved a challenging bug.

More details here: https://faq.hush.is/rpc/z_mergetoaddress.html

I was reading this article last night before I went to sleep; it is where I got the idea to test this...then I woke up in the morning and walla! someone else discovered it. https://github.com/zcash/zcash/pull/2797

``` hush-cli z_mergetoaddress '["RFJ6Hy48EvEjt-addrqDChxqtqsfyF"]' zs1hm0fgfkf7n4wv9ytce6rdvu7ewrzm0zgr3fq3azaddr 0 0 ``` Works for me. ANY_TADDR probably a more notable solution for the GUI #23. Adding the **0** **transparent_limit** is quicker because it doesn't limit to only 50 transactions. The 0 fee probably shouldn't be used if we don't need to; when using 0 fee it transmits more metadata. This is great information; we have solved a challenging bug. More details here: https://faq.hush.is/rpc/z_mergetoaddress.html I was reading this article last night before I went to sleep; it is where I got the idea to test this...then I woke up in the morning and walla! someone else discovered it. https://github.com/zcash/zcash/pull/2797
oDinZu closed this issue 3 years ago
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Milestone
No project
No Assignees
2 Participants
Notifications
Due Date

No due date set.

Dependencies

This issue currently doesn't have any dependencies.

Loading…
There is no content yet.